The NWC/Top 100 SA Wine Challenge assesses entered wines objectively, independently and professionally. Judging panels are comprised of high quality experts. Judges will work in panels of three.  Judges include respected MW’s, international experts, CWM’s as well as winemakers.

Tasting Director – Higgo Jacobs

higgo

Higgo Jacobs is again the dedicated Tasting Director for 2017. He obtained his Court of Master Sommeliers’ Certificate as well as the WSET Advanced qualification whilst working in the UK. Higgo has judged at the IWC in 2007. Higgo is also a respected sommelier and judge in key South African circles. Higgo will oversee flight creation and assembly during the judgement week

Tasting Protocol

The methodology applied is based on international input as well as from analysis and review of world class wine events.  NWC/Top 100 SA Wine Challenge procedures are at the forefront of global best practice.

Wines

  • Six bottles of each wine are available
  • White wines will be served at approximately 14°C
  • Red wines will be served at approximately 19°C
  • Bubblies will be served at approximately 7°C
  • Two bottles are used per tasting flight
  • The Tasting Director will arrange flights and supervise administration.

Glasses

Riedel glassware is used.

Judging Process

  1. NWC/Top 100 SA Wine Challenge Chair is Dr Jamie Goode
  2. Judges are independent and answer only to panel chairs and to Jamie
  3. Wines are tasted blind
  4. Wines are tasted in similar flights
  5. Discussion is allowed for faulty wines and protocol breach
  6. Following the initial tastings, and as an absolute minimum, wines within a certain score band can be re tasted twice further in order to confirm their placement
  7. The 20-point scoring system is applied
  8. There is post flight panel discussion, score calibration and recording
  9. Where discrepancies occur, the panel (firstly) and the Chairman (secondly, who has a casting vote) will attempt to reach consensus between the panel members as to the score awarded for each wine
  10. The panel will record its scores and where appropriate, its comments
  11. Winning wines:
    • The highest scoring wine of each flight will be awarded Grand Cru 1st place
    • A small band of top scoring wines will be awarded Double Platinum status
    • The next band will be awarded Double Gold certification
    • A third band will be awarded double Silver certification
    • The 100 wines that achieve the highest scores will be awarded the elite ‘Top 100 SA Wine’ status and form the 2017 ‘club’
    • (It is likely that the ‘% bands’ of winners will be about 5% for D Platinum; 15% for D Gold and 30% for D Silver)
“A trusted list of wines; buy better wines with confidence”